Publish in this journal
Journal Information
Vol. 68. Issue 7.
Pages 551-553 (July 2015)
DOI: 10.1016/j.rec.2015.03.007
Full text access
Catheter-based Renal Denervation as a Treatment for Pulmonary Hypertension: Hope or Hype?
Denervación renal por catéter como tratamiento para la hipertensión pulmonar: ¿esperanza o espejismo?
Carlos G. Santos-Gallego, Juan José Badimón
Corresponding author

Corresponding author: Atherothrombosis Research Unit, Cardiovascular Institute, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, 1428 Madison Avenue, Atran Building, 6th floor, Room 6.20, New York, NY 10029, United States.
Atherothrombosis Research Unit, Cardiovascular Institute, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, United States
Related content
Rev Esp Cardiol. 2015;68:562-7010.1016/j.rec.2014.11.022
Zhao Qingyan, Jiang Xuejun, Tang Yanhong, Dai Zixuan, Wang Xiaozhan, Wang Xule, Guo Zongwen, Hu Wei, Yu Shengbo, Huang Congxin
This item has received
(Daily data update)
Article information
Full Text
Download PDF
Full Text

Pulmonary arterial hypertension (PAH) is characterized by a progressive increase in pulmonary vascular resistance (PVR) that causes right ventricular (RV) failure and premature death.1 This hypertensive condition leads to precapillary pulmonary hypertension, defined as a mean pulmonary artery pressure (mPAP) ≥ 25mmHg, pulmonary capillary wedge pressure ≤ 15mmHg, and PVR > 3 Wood units at rest. The prevalence of PAH is estimated to range from 15 to 50 patients/million,1 with a female predominance (men:women, 1:2) and 1-year and 5-year survival rates of 85% and 57%, respectively.2 During the last 15 years, treatments for PAH have been studied in multiple clinical trials, with approval subsequently granted for 9 distinct drugs belonging to 4 pharmacological families1,3: prostanoids (epoprostenol, iloprost, treprostinil), endothelin receptor antagonists (bosentan, ambrisentan, macitentan), phosphodiesterase-5 inhibitors (sildenafil, tadalafil), and adenylate cyclase stimulators (riociguat). Despite these therapeutic advances, many patients with PAH show disabling symptoms and an ominous prognosis, underscoring the need for new therapeutic strategies to combat PAH.

The pathophysiology of PAH involves excessive vasoconstriction and vascular remodeling.1 The increased PVR is initially reversible and is due to an imbalance between vasodilatory and vasoconstrictive agents, but can become permanent in later stages. The vascular remodeling is characterized by intimal thickening and fibrosis and the proliferation and migration of vascular smooth muscle cells, with hypertrophy and fibrosis of the tunica media, inflammation, and in situ thrombosis, which trigger the formation of plexiform and obstructive lesions (the most characteristic finding of PAH), all of which lead to RV remodeling. Given our poor understanding of the pathophysiology of PAH, the development of new preclinical models of PAH4,5 and their evaluation using appropriate imaging6 techniques are essential to further our understanding of PAH.

Various studies of PAH patients show a hyperstimulation of the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) that appears to contribute to the development of the condition. This excessive activation of the SNS in PAH is confirmed by both indirect (elevated plasma concentrations of catecholamines7) and direct evidence (muscle sympathetic nerve activity via microneurography of the peroneal nerve,8 heart rate variability,9 and baroreceptor reflex variability9). Additionally, Juratsch et al10 found that the increases in the mPAP and PVR (induced by distension of the pulmonary artery) were completely abolished by both chemical sympathectomy using 6-hydroxydopamine and denervation of the pulmonary sympathetic plexus, but not by vagotomy or hyperoxygenation. All of these findings indicate that PAH can be mediated, at least partly, by SNS hyperactivation.

Given the involvement of the SNS and the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system4,11 in the pathogenesis of PAH, it is tempting to hypothesize that treatments that reduce this neurohormonal activation could be an effective therapeutic strategy for PAH. One of the most noteworthy examples is catheter-based renal denervation (CRD), an intervention that reduces activation of the SNS and the renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system and that was recently studied as a possible treatment for arterial hypertension. In this article of Revista Española de Cardiología, Qingyan et al12 report the first preclinical results of this strategy in a proof-of-concept study that evaluated the efficacy of CRD as a treatment for PAH in a canine experimental model. The authors induced PAH through monocrotaline injection, a universally accepted PAH model. Next, 1 group of dogs underwent CRD (PAH+CRD group), with the remaining dogs serving as the control arm (PAH control group). Compared with the PAH control arm, at the 8-week follow-up, the PAH+CRD group showed better hemodynamic parameters (lower mPAP and PVR), reduced RV remodeling (lower RV and right atrial dilatation by echocardiography, more preserved RV longitudinal strain, and less interstitial fibrosis in the RV myocardium), lower neurohormonal activation (lower plasma and pulmonary tissue concentrations of angiotensin II and endothelin-1, as well as aldosterone and B-type natriuretic peptide [BNP] in the RV), and reduced pulmonary vascular remodeling (less intimal thickening). The authors concluded that CRD is an effective strategy for PAH, because the treatment reduces the elevated pulmonary pressures and adverse remodeling (both of the pulmonary vasculature and the RV) caused by lower neurohormonal activation. These fascinating results must be cautiously analyzed in light of the many limitations of the study.

The authors must be congratulated for the major new development of the study, which is the use of CRD (initially developed for arterial hypertension) to treat PAH by alleviating neurohormonal activation. Catheter-based renal denervation is an interventional procedure that aims to destroy the sympathetic nerve fibers of the renal periarterial nerve plexus via radiofrequency ablation using a catheter that heats the tissue. After the positive results of the SYMPLICITY-213 clinical trial on the treatment of arterial hypertension, researchers began to study the use of CRD to reduce the neurohormonal activation of the SNS in other cardiovascular diseases, such as heart failure14 and atrial fibrillation.15 Indeed, a similar approach to that of Qingyan et al12 for PAH treatment is to reduce the activation of the SNS specifically in the lung via catheter-based pulmonary artery denervation. As described above, Juratsch et al10 found increases in the mPAP and PVR in response to balloon distension of the pulmonary artery; these increases were completely abolished by surgical denervation of the pulmonary artery bifurcation and chemical sympathectomy. These results indicated that the efferent branch of this pulmo-pulmonary reflex is mediated by the SNS. In a study in dogs,16 balloon occlusion of the left interlobar pulmonary artery increased the mPAP and PVR, which normalized following catheter-based denervation of the pulmonary artery. In a subsequent study in patients with PAH,17 catheter-based denervation of the pulmonary artery induced immediate reductions in systolic and mean pulmonary pressures (from 86±8 to 72±5mmHg and from 55±5 to 39±7 mmHg, respectively) and PVR, as well as improvements in the 6-minute walking test (from 324±21 to 491±38 m) and in the tricuspid excursion index (from 0.7±0.04 to 0.50±0.041). Importantly, however, this first clinical study included only 21 patients who were not randomized and were followed-up for only 3 months. The composition of the population was also unusual (there was no elevation of right atrial pressure, suggesting that the PAH in these patients was relatively mild).

One of the problems prior to the present study12 is our lack of understanding of the specific effect of the SNS on pulmonary hypertension. A recent study18 showed that the drug nebivolol—an antagonist of β1 adrenergic receptors but an agonist of β2 and β3 adrenoceptors—reduces pulmonary vascular remodeling and induces nitric oxide-mediated vasodilation in the pulmonary artery, thereby attenuating the hemodynamic severity of pulmonary hypertension and mitigating RV remodeling. The effects of nebivolol seem to be derived from activation of a particular beta receptor, because the selective beta-blocker metoprolol lacks these beneficial effects. Thus, the effect of each specific adrenoceptor on pulmonary hypertension must be elucidated before modulating the entire SNS using CRD.

The most evident limitation of the Qingyan et al12 study is its experimental design, because the authors performed the CRD immediately after the injection of monocrotaline, that is, before the PAH had been established and before the mPAP had begun to increase. This experimental design supports the involvement of the sympathetic system in the pathophysiology of PAH but fails to probe the effectiveness of CRD or to reflect the clinical situation (where patients receive treatment after years of chronically elevated pulmonary pressure). A more suitable design would have been induction of PAH with monocrotaline at the beginning of the study, with CRD performed once the mPAP is elevated and established (eg, 2-3 months after monocrotaline injection); the final evaluation of therapeutic efficacy would occur at the end of the study (2-3 months after CRD or 4-6 months after PAH induction). This new alternative design adequately reflects clinical practice, where patients with PAH only receive treatment once PAH is established. In contrast, in the original design of Qingyan et al,12 CRD is used as prophylaxis to avoid later PAH development (a setting that markedly differs from clinical reality).

Second, the biological plausibility of CRD is not fully evident. This acute experimental model cannot be considered representative of the PVR increase in patients with chronic PAH. Vasoconstriction is only one of the pathophysiological mechanisms involved in PAH; in fact, in patients with PAH who fail to respond to a vasoreactivity test, the main mechanism of PVR is vascular remodeling due to obstructive and fixed lesions and proliferation of vascular smooth muscle cells. Thus, theoretically, CRD could abolish functional vasoconstriction, but it is doubtful that the intervention could induce inverse remodeling of severe and obstructive lesions in distal pulmonary arteries. CRD might be effective in initial stages, when PAH is being established, but not in the more advanced stages (when PAH is already chronically established), and the present study is unable to provide information on the effectiveness of CRD in such advanced stages. This limitation is vitally important because, given that CRD is neither noninvasive nor risk free, it will surely not be applied in early stages of PAH, but in more advanced stages.

Third, another limitation of the study by Qingyan et al12 is the lack of understanding of the perirenal plexus nerve lesions produced by CRD. The authors of the article failed to study the degree of nerve damage after CRD application in this experimental model or to determine whether a greater percentage of destroyed nerves correlated with lower PVR or lower plasma concentrations of catecholamines or angiotensin II. Perhaps the authors can still take advantage of some of the immunohistochemical stains frequently used to study the plexus nerves19–21: the presence of intact and functional sympathetic axons within the nerve fascicles can be identified using immunohistochemistry for tyrosine hydroxylase—a functional marker of norepinephrine synthesis—, the nerve damage in stromal elements (nerve fascicles) can be assessed with immunohistochemistry for S-100, and the afferent fibers can be marked with CGRP (calcitonin gene-related peptide). This is a topical issue, given that one of the possible reasons for the neutral results of the SIMPLICITY-322 study is that CRD incompletely injures the renal plexus; consequently, if an incomplete renal denervation is unable to improve arterial hypertension, such a denervation approach is perhaps unlikely to be effective for PAH.

Crucially, the authors have not performed a long-term study of the model (only 8 weeks from the CRD). A recent study21 showed that nerve injury (evaluated using immunohistochemistry for tyrosine hydroxylase) following CRD was highest in the acute phase, but this damage began to mitigate from 60 days, and there was even focal nerve regeneration in the long-term, indicating a gradual recovery. This nerve regeneration would theoretically limit the benefits of CRD in the long term, precisely the duration that was not studied by the authors.

An additional limitation of the study by Qingyan et al12 is the lack of a simulation (sham) group, because the HAP+control group underwent HAP induction without catheter insertion. One of the possible reasons for the difference between the success of the SYMPLICITY-213 trial and the neutral results of the SYMPLICITY-322 study is that the former trial lacked a sham group (with the placebo effect possibly explaining the mPAP reduction seen in the control group); in contrast, the SYMPLICITY-3 trial included a sham group. Although the placebo effect does appear to be much more important in humans, there may still be some effect associated with the insertion of the catheter into the renal arteries.

In summary, Qingyan et al12 should be congratulated for the novelty of the study and its promising and appealing results on the potential use of CRD as a therapeutic strategy for the treatment of PAH. However, the study should only be considered a hypothesis generator. Thus, additional carefully designed and exhaustively evaluated preclinical experiments (which include a chronic model of PAH) should confirm these results and answer questions about the safety and efficacy of denervation before the procedure can advance to the clinical trial phase (which would include an appropriate control/sham group). Hence, the title of this editorial: much is promised by these results (hope), but care must be taken to avoid the generation of unrealistic expectations (hype).


None declared.

N. Galie, M.M. Hoeper, M. Humbert, A. Torbicki, J.L. Vachiery, J.A. Barbera, et al.
Guidelines for the diagnosis and treatment of pulmonary hypertension: the Task Force for the Diagnosis and Treatment of Pulmonary Hypertension of the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) and the European Respiratory Society (ERS), endorsed by the International Society of Heart and Lung Transplantation (ISHLT).
Eur Heart J., 30 (2009), pp. 2493-2537
R.L. Benza, D.P. Miller, R.J. Barst, D.B. Badesch, A.E. Frost, M.D. McGoon.
An evaluation of long-term survival from time of diagnosis in pulmonary arterial hypertension from the REVEAL Registry.
Chest., 142 (2012), pp. 448-456
M. Humbert, E.M. Lau, D. Montani, X. Jais, O. Sitbon, G. Simonneau.
Advances in therapeutic interventions for patients with pulmonary arterial hypertension.
Circulation., 130 (2014), pp. 2189-2208
J. Aguero, K. Ishikawa, L. Hadri, C. Santos-Gallego, K. Fish, N. Hammoudi, et al.
Characterization of right ventricular remodeling and failure in a chronic pulmonary hypertension model.
Am J Physiol Heart Circ Physiol., 307 (2014), pp. H1204-H1215
D. Pereda, A. Garcia-Alvarez, D. Sanchez-Quintana, M. Nuno, L. Fernandez-Friera, R. Fernandez-Jimenez, et al.
Swine model of chronic postcapillary pulmonary hypertension with right ventricular remodeling: long-term characterization by cardiac catheterization, magnetic resonance, and pathology.
J Cardiovasc Transl Res., 7 (2014), pp. 494-506
A. Garcia-Alvarez, L. Fernandez-Friera, J.M. Garcia-Ruiz, M. Nuno-Ayala, D. Pereda, R. Fernandez-Jimenez, et al.
Noninvasive monitoring of serial changes in pulmonary vascular resistance and acute vasodilator testing using cardiac magnetic resonance.
J Am Coll Cardiol., 62 (2013), pp. 1621-1631
N. Nagaya, T. Nishikimi, M. Uematsu, T. Satoh, S. Kyotani, F. Sakamaki, et al.
Plasma brain natriuretic peptide as a prognostic indicator in patients with primary pulmonary hypertension.
Circulation., 102 (2000), pp. 865-870
S. Velez-Roa, A. Ciarka, B. Najem, J.L. Vachiery, R. Naeije, P. Van de Borne.
Increased sympathetic nerve activity in pulmonary artery hypertension.
Circulation., 110 (2004), pp. 1308-1312
R. Wensel, C. Jilek, M. Dorr, D.P. Francis, H. Stadler, T. Lange, et al.
Impaired cardiac autonomic control relates to disease severity in pulmonary hypertension.
Eur Respir J., 34 (2009), pp. 895-901
C.E. Juratsch, J.A. Jengo, J. Castagna, M.M. Laks.
Experimental pulmonary hypertension produced by surgical and chemical denervation of the pulmonary vasculature.
Chest., 77 (1980), pp. 525-530
F.S. De Man, L. Tu, M.L. Handoko, S. Rain, G. Ruiter, C. Francois, et al.
Dysregulated renin-angiotensin-aldosterone system contributes to pulmonary arterial hypertension.
Am J Respir Crit Care Med., 186 (2012), pp. 780-789
Z. Qingyan, J. Xuejun, T. Yanhong, D. Zixuan, W. Xiaozhan, W. Xule, et al.
Efectos beneficiosos de la simpatectomía renal sobre el remodelado vascular pulmonar en la hipertensión arterial primaria experimental.
Rev Esp Cardiol., 68 (2015), pp. 562-570
M.D. Esler, H. Krum, P.A. Sobotka, M.P. Schlaich, R.E. Schmieder, M. Bohm.
Renal sympathetic denervation in patients with treatment-resistant hypertension (The Symplicity HTN-2 Trial): a randomised controlled trial.
Lancet., 376 (2010), pp. 1903-1909
J.E. Davies, C.H. Manisty, R. Petraco, A.J. Barron, B. Unsworth, J. Mayet, et al.
First-in-man safety evaluation of renal denervation for chronic systolic heart failure: primary outcome from REACH-Pilot study.
Int J Cardiol., 162 (2013), pp. 189-192
E. Pokushalov, A. Romanov, G. Corbucci, S. Artyomenko, V. Baranova, A. Turov, et al.
A randomized comparison of pulmonary vein isolation with versus without concomitant renal artery denervation in patients with refractory symptomatic atrial fibrillation and resistant hypertension.
J Am Coll Cardiol., 60 (2012), pp. 1163-1170
S.L. Chen, Y.J. Zhang, L. Zhou, D.J. Xie, F.F. Zhang, H.B. Jia, et al.
Percutaneous pulmonary artery denervation completely abolishes experimental pulmonary arterial hypertension in vivo.
EuroIntervention., 9 (2013), pp. 269-276
S.L. Chen, F.F. Zhang, J. Xu, D.J. Xie, L. Zhou, T. Nguyen, et al.
Pulmonary artery denervation to treat pulmonary arterial hypertension: the single-center, prospective, first-in-man PADN-1 study (first-in-man pulmonary artery denervation for treatment of pulmonary artery hypertension).
J Am Coll Cardiol., 62 (2013), pp. 1092-1100
F. Perros, B. Ranchoux, M. Izikki, S. Bentebbal, C. Happe, F. Antigny, et al.
Nebivolol for improving endothelial dysfunction, pulmonary vascular remodeling, and right heart function in pulmonary hypertension.
J Am Coll Cardiol., 65 (2015), pp. 668-680
K. Sakakura, E. Ladich, Q. Cheng, F. Otsuka, K. Yahagi, D.R. Fowler, et al.
Anatomic assessment of sympathetic peri-arterial renal nerves in man.
J Am Coll Cardiol., 64 (2014), pp. 635-643
K. Sakakura, E. Ladich, E.R. Edelman, P. Markham, J.R. Stanley, J. Keating, et al.
Methodological standardization for the pre-clinical evaluation of renal sympathetic denervation.
JACC Cardiovasc Interv., 7 (2014), pp. 1184-1193
K. Sakakura, S. Tunev, K. Yahagi, A.J. O’Brien, E. Ladich, F.D. Kolodgie, et al.
Comparison of histopathologic analysis following renal sympathetic denervation over multiple time points.
Circ Cardiovasc Interv., 8 (2015), pp. e001813
D.L. Bhatt, D.E. Kandzari, W.W. O’Neill, R. D’Agostino, J.M. Flack, B.T. Katzen, et al.
A controlled trial of renal denervation for resistant hypertension.
N Engl J Med., 370 (2014), pp. 1393-1401
Copyright © 2015. Sociedad Española de Cardiología
Revista Española de Cardiología (English Edition)

Subscribe to our newsletter

Article options
es en

¿Es usted profesional sanitario apto para prescribir o dispensar medicamentos?

Are you a health professional able to prescribe or dispense drugs?

es en
Política de cookies Cookies policy
Utilizamos cookies propias y de terceros para mejorar nuestros servicios y mostrarle publicidad relacionada con sus preferencias mediante el análisis de sus hábitos de navegación. Si continua navegando, consideramos que acepta su uso. Puede cambiar la configuración u obtener más información aquí. To improve our services and products, we use "cookies" (own or third parties authorized) to show advertising related to client preferences through the analyses of navigation customer behavior. Continuing navigation will be considered as acceptance of this use. You can change the settings or obtain more information by clicking here.